Monthly Archives: January 2012

Reason thus with life

Partly at the suggestion of T. David Gordon, I have taken up the project of reading through Harold Bloom’s wonderful The Best Poems of the English Language: from Chaucer through Robert Frost. Gordon argues brilliantly that, in order to be able to write, it is first of all necessary to be able to read, and to do be able to read something as a text — that is, not merely for its content, but for its literary form and beauty. C. S. Lewis describes beautifully what this entails in a quote posted earlier. One of the best ways to continue to grow in this ability is to maintain a steady diet of poetry. I have admired in this regard the consistency of James K. A. Smith, for example, and am now endeavoring to do something similar. Once I complete this volume, I hope to join my wife in reading Poetry magazine.

My intention through this project is to post favorite selections here as I come across them. We begin with a selection from Shakespeare’s Measure for Measure (Bloom, p. 122).

Be absolute for death; either death or life
Shall thereby be the sweeter. Reason thus with life:
If I do lose thee, I do lose a thing
That none but fools would keep: a breath thou art,
Servile to all the skyey influences,
That dost this habitation, where thou keep’st,
Hourly afflict: merely, thou art death’s fool;
For him thou labour’st by thy flight to shun
And yet runn’st toward him still.

The Age-old Promised Thing

“The story [of the Gospel of Luke] is thus one of movement and fulfillment; movement and mission; God and his promises to Abraham; God and Abraham’s seed; God and his covenant with David; God and recalcitrant Israel; God and renewed Israel; God and the nations he said he would bless: for God himself is on the move (keeping promises, answering prayer, filling a people, working  miracles, stretching out his hand, setting prisoners free, spreading his people abroad, and overseeing their participation in his redemptive mission). God is doing something new in the world – first through his Spirit-empowered servant Jesus (3:22; 4:1, 14, 18-19) and then (and now) through the Spirit-filled followers of Jesus (11:11-13; 24:48-49; Acts 1:4-8; 2:1-21). But this new thing is the age-old promised thing, the thing for which faithful Israel had for so long been waiting. The story of national Israel has reached its divinely intended climax – it is time for Yahweh’s renewed temple-people to be a house of prayer made up of all nations.” (Craig G. Bartholomew and Robby Holt, ”Prayer in/and the Drama of Redemption in Luke” in Reading Luke: Interpretation, Reflection, Formation, Bartholomew, et. al. eds., p. 360)

Think of the Bridge!

As part of an exhortation to preach Christ in a non-introspective way, T. David Gordon offers the following wonderful quote in his Why Johnny Can’t Preach (pp. 76-77). The Southern Presbyterian theologian Robert Lewis Dabney knew that his death was drawing near and wrote to his old friend Vaughan, expressing his doubts about the strength of his faith in the face of death. Vaughan responded to Dabney with the illustration of a traveler who was to cross a bridge over a chasm:

“What does he do to breed confidence in the bridge? He looks at the bridge; he gets down and examines it. He don’t [sic] stand at the bridge-head and turn his thoughts curiously in on his own mind to see if he has confidence in the bridge. If his examination of the bridge gives him a certain amount of confidence, and yet he wants more, how does he make his faith grow? Why, in the same way; he still continues to examine the bridge. Now, my dear old man, let your faith take care of itself for awhile, and you just think of what you are allowed to trust in. Think of the Master’s power, think of his love; think how he is interested in the soul that searches for him, and will not be comforted until he finds him. Think of what he has done, his work. That blood of his is mightier than all the sins of all the sinners that ever lived. Don’t you think it will master yours?…

“Now, dear old friend, I have done to you just what I would want you to do to me if I were lying in your place. The great theologian, after all, is just like any other one of God’s children, and the simple gospel talked to him is just as essential to his comfort as it is to a milk-maid or to a plow-boy. May God give you grace, not to lay too much stress on your faith, but to grasp the great ground of confidence, Christ, and all his work and all his personal fitness to be a sinner’s refuge. Faith is only an eye to see him. I have been praying that God would quiet your pains as you advance, and enable you to see the gladness of the gospel at every step. Good-bye. God be with you as he will. Think of the bridge! Your brother, C. R. V.”

What They Were Not Before

‘Speaking of the difference between those who “receive” literature versus those who merely “use” it, C. S. Lewis said, “The first reading of some literary work is often, to the literary, so momentous that only experiences of love, religion, or bereavement can furnish a standard of comparison. Their whole consciousness is changed. They have become what they were not before. But there is no sign of anything like this among the other sort of readers. When they have finished the story or the novel, nothing much, or nothing at all, seems to have happened to them.”‘ Experiment in Criticism, p. 3, cited in T. David Gordon, Why Johnny Can’t Preach, p. 50.

Strongest Impressions of 2011

Jeffrey Overstreet has been our guide for film viewing for the last several years. We’ve always found his reviews to be insightful, and he’s certainly led us into a deeper appreciation for the poetic and artistic character of good film. A great place to start is with his yearly top ten lists. Here are his lists for 1980-2010. He recently released his lists for 2011, in two parts:

Strongest Impressions of 2011, Part 1

Strongest Impressions of 2011, Part 2

I should also mention that Overstreet is a talented novelist. His books are all worth reading.

While not as canonical for us as his film reviews, his list of top albums for 2011 was just published as well.